Didi Sees Red Over Rat-Bite at Hospital: Blames CPM of Playing the Pied Piper

Toi reportWest Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee has done it yet again — let her fertile imagination run riot. She was at her asinine best when she recently accused her favourite bete noir, the CPI(M), of letting loose rats at the SSKM hospital, where a 53-year-old woman had allegedly died of rat-bite on December 23.

For the uninitiated, lest I be accused of letting my imagination run riot here and blaming perhaps my favourite punching bag, here’s is the proof, courtesy The Times of IndiaRat bite death in West Bengal: Hospital orders probe, Mamata alleges CPM role.

The chief minister’s reaction came after the rat-bite incident was highlighted by some TV channels. “The media inclined to CPM are running live shows on this rat incident. They have only created this incident. I think they have only left the rats there,” the TOI report quoted Banerjee.

Now, there is no denying the fact that govt hospitals in West Bengal used to be in a pitiable state. Besides lacking in medical facilities and infrastructure, they are often infested with cockroaches, bedbugs, ants, rodents, dogs and even pigs. After the ‘Paribartan’ that had swept her to power, Banerjee’s first priority, as in-charge of the health portfolio, was to improve the condition of the hospitals. She had even suspended the director of a hospital who had objected to the crowd (read supporters and mediapersons) accompanying her on her visit to the campus.

Thus, it wouldn’t be wrong to assume that a ‘Paribartan’ had indeed taken place in state-run hospitals too. In fact, Banerjee herself had visited SSKM several times during her seven-month regime and surely would have noticed that the hospital was bereft of any four-legged creatures. Thus, the re-appearance of a rat at SSKM in her regime is surely a deep-rooted conspiracy hatched by the CPM. The CPM must have employed a modern-day Pied Piper who let in a swarm of rats in SSKM.

The incident surely demands a CID/CBI probe. But of course, the chief minister has lightened the burden of the fact-finding committee by declaring the identity of the culprit well in advance.

Mamata

Banerjee perhaps suffers from a split personality -- there are times when her "Opposition" avatar makes her forget who is in charge now.

Social media networks like Facebook have been abuzz with reaction following the comment. There were some acid comments like had the chief minister’s mother passed away at SSKM during the Left regime, the CPM would have definitely been blamed for “negligence” and a Bangla Bandh would have followed. Questions were asked whether her mother’s attending physicians were suspended. Some were astonished that she did not see a CPM hand in the AMRI fire tragedy.

But of course, it is not the right sort of comments to be posted on a public forum! Banerjee had threatened to clamp down on Facebook and all such social media networks (where her detractors were busy maligning her) even before Union communications minister Kapil Sibal came up with the bright idea. Those crediting or blaming Sibal for the clampdown, should read my earlier post: Facebook Users Beware: Every Post you Make, Didi’s Watching.

Anyway, back to our Pied Piper story. The rat-bite incident had followed the Hooch tragedy at a village in South 24-Parganas district that claimed 173 lives. Here again, the CM had smelled a CPM conspiracy in spreading rumors of drinking water being contaminated. The Left had predictably reacted sharply. Dr Surjya Kanta Mishra, the leader of Opposition in the state, accused the chief minister of encouraging “poisoned politics”. He reminded that Mamata herself, while in the Opposition, had spread rumours like the CPM would mix poison to the drinking water in Tallah, the main source of drinking water in Kolkata.

Such unwanted comments coming from the CM speaks volumes about the insecurity she is suffering from. And it is this insecurity that is difficult to understand. Why does a political leader, who swept to power with overwhelming popular support after decimating a party that had been in power for 34 years, suffer from such paranoia? What is that she is scared of?

One answer perhaps is that responsibility and Banerjee do not go together. She was a good Opposition leader — raising hue and cry at the drop of the hat — and now suffers from a split personality. There are times perhaps when the “Opposition Mamata” overpowers the “CM Mamata” and she blames CPM of everything wrong with the state. It is either that, or she has begun to find the crown too uneasy to wear.

But I am diverting again. Back to the Pied Piper story. Her rat-bite reaction perhaps beats all her previous quotable quotes like the massive floods in the state in 2000 were man-made or CPM engineered the train collision in Sainthia in July 2010 ands such.

All said and done, a probe into the SSKM incident would hopefully unearth the famed Pied Piper, which should be the greatest find of the century, a discovery that would certainly earn her a place at Madame Tussaud’s, if not a nomination for a Nobel Prize!

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Soumya Datta

About Soumya Datta

The author is a sports aficionado, having participated in various forms of sports like football, cricket, hockey, table tennis since school days.He is an avid watcher of English Premiership League and a die-hard supporter of Arsenal.
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
joydeep chatterjee 8 pts

soumya datta

Soumya da, Congrats once again for this wonderful article. Sorry for being so late in sharing my views.

I was late by a week, I suppose, and what an eventful week it was. The principal of a college was beaten up by the outsiders<read ‘Samaj Sevaks’>.I don’t want to sensitize my comment by posting this small incident<’Tilke Tal’>.My focus should be the origin of this.

We should not forget that her origin of evolution is power<kindly remember the flow of incidents of forming TMC> and that too of a congress culture. The essence of congress culture of power, dominance, groups are deep routed in her thinking. So she might show off the simplicity pattern, but the problem is ‘majhe majhe jhuli theke biral ta beriyei pore’.

Jokes apart, I must say, she is our CM now, not the opposition leader. The order of the post demands more patience, more logical, rational way of expressing your views. People of Bengal has given her a mandate for change. She should understand that the opposition backed by progressive criticism is the strongest part in democracy.

aliviasengupta123 5 pts

i think you should not have mentioned anything about anybody's demise ,be it for any reason. You yourself has mentioned that "But of course, it is not the right sort of comments to be posted on a public forum".

At least due to Parivartan the govt hospitals have regained some status. We have read in the newspaper that outdoors are being opened sharp at time with the fear in mind that "DIDI MAY COME TODAY ". Some change ,may not be very prominent in this nascent period ,but still is visible ..Change is there !! and knocked the door .. ...But i think nobody can change her nature of blaming her favourite opposition party ! .

.I think its not about fear ,not about anything related to insecurity ,,not about the dreaded fear of losing her Royal Crown ...it simply clears out her stress and helps her to remain kewl !!

Anusuya Datta 26 pts

aliviasengupta123 wow! what a reason for blaming others -- just because u have stress, blame your favpourite opposition. So from tomorow, manmohan singh should just blame BJP for the inflation, corruption and what not ailing his govt. And now, that bin laden is dead Obama should look for someone else to blame for the condition of US economy. Isn't that downright stupid? Doesn't it sound like the moronic Pakistanis? Any problems -- even floods -- blame India?

arnie41178 11 pts

Anusuya Dattaaliviasengupta123 Yes ...Once "Didi" blamed CPM for a flood...the great "Man Made Flood"....

Anusuya Datta 26 pts

Soumyada, can we see a piece on didi's quotable quotes? much like those articles floating on the net in George W bush's haydays... Who (Hu) is the president of China?... :D

SoumyaChatterjee 11 pts

when u r batting against Kenya U can never score a century against Australia... just like this if West Bengal is a state in India it can never be expected to have the parameters of the western civilised countries. She has to get this in her head sooner rather than later, no matter which party rule it some problems wud persist becoz of the poor infrastructure of the nation.Its a very easy way out to blame everything on the Left, maybe a group of people who wud actually believe her when she says this but for the larger group I dont think its acceptable... she came to power with this slogan " era 34 bochor-a eta koreni ami apnader kore dekhiye debo" now wen she is supposed to do "it" she is hiding behind the "oder shorojontro" masquerade.... dont no kotodin eta cholbe..dont know manush kotodin eta khabe.... aj theke 25 bochor age uni naamer age Dr. likhten ekhon r likhte paren na setao ki ei " bamponthi harmaad-der sorojontre" ???

anindya ghose 10 pts

A great piece of writing, unlike a number of people the author has the guts to call a spade a spade.

In school days read about Muhammed Bin Tughlaq, later in life came to know about people who can be termed as 'Megalomaniacs'.....but none of those gems could surpass the lady at the helm. She is - the jewel in the crown.

I blame the CPIM in particular & the Left in general for a number of their deeds in the last 34 years.....but the most important reason they should be blamed for is their deeds that brought these people to power.

While reading about Tagore came to know that the educated Bengalis of that time wished (& some had) their children named by him. A number of buildings in Santiniketan were named by him but, I presume, that total number has been surpassed by the 'jewel in the crown'....old, new & would be Metro stations have been renamed & named by her. Latest addition - from 'Indira Bhavan' to 'Nazrul Bhavan'. Both the late PMs must be turning in their graves!!!!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] all accidents, mishaps, murder, mayhem, load-shedding and short-circuits across the state. (Read: Didi Sees Red Over Rat-Bite at Hospital: Blames CPM of Playing the Pied Piper)It is also learnt from learned sources that the CM opposed FDI in retail, as fancied by the PM, [...]

  2. [...] Playing a Bengali was off the list already.Now if you are Bengali and have an elder sister, sorry Didi, who can’t stand the colour red, pray hard that those who wear red don’t get blamed for the Thane cyclone that hit Tamil [...]

  3. [...] do the job, why blame her and her government? And didn’t she clarify that incidents like the rat-bite death at PGI was again a CMP conspiracy?Then, some people talk of daylight robberies and murders. There are others who talk about heads of [...]